VillaAula
Log in
Lesson 1 / 4

CRITIQUE · HEDGED CRITICISM

Reading crit feedback

Pro tip — how it's said in English

Written crit feedback is usually hedged — the real note hides inside polite phrasing:

  • "I'd push the section further" = the section isn't resolved yet.
  • "It's an interesting choice to…" = I'm not convinced by…
  • "What's driving this?" = I can't see the logic; justify it.

Read for the note under the politeness — that's the work to do.

Progress0 / 3 correct
📝

Notes from the panel

"There's a lot to like here. The plan is clear and the model is beautifully made. I would say the section is doing less than the plan — I'd push it further. And I'm curious what's driving the choice of brick on the north face; it reads as a default rather than a decision. But the bones are strong. Resolve the section and you have a project."

1

What is the panel's main piece of work for the student?

2

“It reads as a default rather than a decision” about the brick means…

3

Despite the criticism, the panel thinks the underlying project is strong.

Saved on this device