CONTEXT · CHOICES · CONSEQUENCES
Learning objective: Give specific feedback, listen for context, and agree on a useful change without labeling a person's character.
Source status: Course-authored teaching based on a reported topic map. Linked references describe the versions taught here. Original workshop diagrams, homework, and organization-specific procedures were not supplied.
A project member writes “obvious mistake” on several reviews. A useful private opening is: “In yesterday's review, two comments called the changes obvious mistakes without explaining a correction. The author stopped asking questions and the review stalled. What were you trying to communicate?” Let them explain time pressure or context without erasing the effect.
Next, agree on a change: describe the technical issue, explain the reason, and suggest a next step. Ask what support would help, and review a later example together. If you were mistaken about the events, correct your account. If the disagreement is about a tradeoff, discuss the evidence rather than disguising your preference as objective misconduct.
The supplied topic map names SBIQ, but does not define its Q. This course teaches the independently documented SBI and a separate open question; it does not claim these reproduce the missing workshop variant.
Limit: a feedback formula cannot guarantee trust. Public correction, vague anonymous claims, and rehearsed praise can undermine a conversation. Protect room for disagreement while still addressing harmful behavior and maintaining standards.
Write one specific recognition message and a private feedback opening for someone who repeatedly interrupts planning. Include an open question, a proposed change, and a follow-up.
Write your response before comparing it with the example.
0/7000
Which recognition is most informative?
What is an example of checking understanding?